I’ve been monitoring the English-speaking world’s response to the Mumbai attacks of last week, and in that time I’ve encountered (out of dozens) one editorial cartoon and one column that actually cut to the heart of the matter.
If you go to Daryl Cagle’s archive of political toons, you’ll find a subsection on the Mumbai attacks. Some of the images are clearly angry; some are reflective; some are mournful — but only one actually seems to get to the point, and it wasn’t even included in the Mumbai subsection. For the most part, you sense the outrage; but there’s almost a subtle squeamishness (to my mind) about the source of the outrage. It’s almost as though the cartoonists don’t want to directly state what the root of the Mumbai atrocity was.
Similarly, commentary has arisen from multitudinous keyboards but I find myself in agreement only with one column, and it’s written by Thomas Friedman, of all people.
In a recent piece he begins by pointing out how furious the reaction was in, ahem, Certain Quarters to the publication of a Danish cartoonist’s mockery of Mohammed in 2006, and has this to offer:
[W]hile the Pakistani government’s sober response [to the Mumbai killings] is important, and the sincere expressions of outrage by individual Pakistanis are critical, I am still hoping for more. I am still hoping — just once — for that mass demonstration of “ordinary people” against the Mumbai bombers, not for my sake, not for India’s sake, but for Pakistan’s sake.
This is pointing to the crux, the heart of the issue that no one really wants to face. Those ten murderous psychopaths in India were not working with a “previously unknown” group, whether or not they were “stateless” (as Pakistani authorities said initially). Friedman does not explicitly delineate here who these “ordinary people” are, but he goes on to say:
We know from the Danish cartoons affair that Pakistanis and other Muslims know how to mobilize quickly to express their heartfelt feelings, not just as individuals, but as a powerful collective. That is what is needed here.
And there it is, a bit more starkly. While some of the toons on Cagle’s site seem to indict Pakistan, and many others bewail generic terrorism, virtually no one seems to want to point to the actual problem.
Read the rest of this entry »